
A talk given at the Salmon Chase Center’s first Conference on Civic Thought, Education, and Leadership, on Friday, Sept. 27, 2025 (civil calendar), in Columbus, Ohio, by Priest Paul Siewers. (Above) An Orthodox Christian icon of St. John receiving the Revelation to write his book on the Apocalypse.
Mainly I’m here to tell a brief story, a story about a formerly Baptist university in central Pennsylvania that lost its way, and networks of alumni, faculty, and students trying to help it survive and thrive again as a liberal arts organization. My title comes from Robby George of Princeton, who said that as an academic across a few decades he liked to “raise the jolly Roger” to disrupt the academic status quo. That’s what this story is about on a small scale.
Let me start in the middle. Last year I was teaching a journalism class on campus at my university, Bucknell. I assigned one group of students to report and write an article for a campus publication on free speech at our university. They came back to me and said that they had interviewed a group of students but that they all said they were too afraid to speak on campus about their views. But then my students said the would rather not use their names on the byline themselves. So we faced an article in a campus newspaper that potentially would have all anonymous sources and anonymous authors, focused on the issue of student views of campus free speech.
But this was more than just about free speech, it was about the quality of a liberal arts education at U.S. residential universities and colleges today. To be clear, I love and am grateful for Bucknell, a fine university where I am in my third decade of teaching now, and for her students. Her situation here is used not to single out Bucknell as worse than other institutions, because she is in many ways in my view better, but to note how she shares in a national crisis in the liberal arts related to the downfall of American civil discourse and reasoning.
A few days before the recent Charlie Kirk assassination, the FIRE organization released its annual rankings, which included survey data showing that 1 in 5 Bucknell students felt that violence could sometimes be justified in stopping a speaker. This took me back a few years to when Professor Mark Bray of Rutgers appeared on campus, to speak at our showcase Humanities Center, about the virtue of pre-emptive violence. Bray seemed to be an Antifa enthusiast. He said that pre-emptive violence against fascists was needed. Then when asked by a student exactly whom he would define as fascists, Bray gave as an example Trump voters. Well, that was probably a good segment of our students and their families. Yet there was no other view represented at the program to debate him on this, and no kind of alternative speaker or rebuttal was ever scheduled despite objections.
These examples, which may be familiar from other campuses, illustrate the normalizing of not only opposing free speech but reason at many universities. If it is true that the fish rots from the head down, and I have suggestions as to likely culprits in all this, based on experience. Three years ago at Bucknell, a small group of us on the faculty proposed adoption of the Chicago Principles to support free expression. The Bucknell faculty voted this down almost unanimously, but did so in a way that was telling. They voted to table the motion indefinitely. In doing so they prevented any discussion. They thus silenced all voices in considering a free-speech motion.
It’s hard to make these things up. But I will go one dimension further and say, that what I have encountered over the years with some of my most ideologically motivated colleagues is that more than fascism, it is traditional Christian culture that they hate. I know this firsthand from various personal experiences at the academic workplace and in our college-town community. Suffice it to say that the very core roots of the liberal arts tradition, dating back into Christian Late Antiquity, are not only under attack, but if the garden metaphor is to be extended, have been treated to a very toxic herbicidal treatment in higher education across a number of years.
At Bucknell, we have had a small group of faculty with a few staff who organized what is now called the Bucknell Program for American Leadership, to stand up for free expression in the liberal arts tradition. After the administration originally promised a group of alumni, concerned about the types of situations I have outlined, that the university would make this group a center, an early micro version of the Chase Center here perhaps, that promise was later reneged upon in the immediately ensuing turmoil of the era of George Floyd and Covid.
Then the alumni in a sense went one better, and founded their own off-campus foundation, called the Open Discourse Coalition, to offer programming promoting civil reasoned discourse. The Open Discourse Coalition is now headquartered in a landmark bank building in the middle of our downtown. It includes fellows who are the current mayor and former congressman from our area, from different political parties.
It is not a conservative or a Christian organization per se, but includes in its ranks of alumni some liberals and libertarians, Jews, agnostics, and atheists. But many are conservatives and conservative Christians of various types. It sponsors programming on campus such as a few projects I’m involved in that I’ll tell you about. It’s been successful in drawing currently about one-tenth of Bucknell’s 4,000 students to its events or seminars. The Open Discourse Coalition’s flagship program is a yearly Leadership Seminar that meets several Saturdays in the first part of fall semester and includes some student engagement with expert guest speakers at other times. The seminar is taught by an award-winning former Professor of Management at Bucknell, William Gruver, who is also a former Vice President at Goldman Sachs. Bill draws a diverse group of Bucknell students who in the past few years have come to see the Leadership Seminar rightly as an elite educational experience in the liberal arts.
Back on campus, I have pondered how the alumni support for the Open Discourse Coalition can help university curriculum enew the liberal arts at a campus where they are in trouble as they are at so many other campuses. Rhetoric, grammar, dialectic, music, astronomy, mathematics, geometry—I can make a good case for still being able to connect major university fields with theese seven sisters of the liberal arts. CS Lewis described for me the liberal arts when he said, you can’t dissect a butterfly to find out why it is beautiful, because then you will have neither beauty nor a butterfly.
I think the many meanigs of the Greek term logos connect and renew the liberal arts, especially in the way that logos means both reason and harmony. This puts a different spin on reason, as not being just logically abstract, but including the living poetics of the music of the spheres and also “story,” which is another meaning of logos, too. Of course the ultimate meaning of Logos for Christians is a name for a person of the Holy Trinity, Christ the Logos. CS Lewis associated the term logos also with what he called the Tao of natural law in his book The Abolition of Man, the logoi of the Logos being the harmonies of the Harmony. Indeed, a Chinese symbol for the Dao (Tao) has often been used to translate the Greek term Logos. Take away the larger sense of the Tao or the Logos or natural law from the liberal arts, and you lose the linchpin of how universities were founded, whether in Paris or Constantinople, in ancient times. You end up with Lewis’ fictional account of a college campus in That Hideous Strength, which I’m reading with a class this semester. It’s a small college in a small town with a grove at its center, much like Bucknell as my students note. Yet like much of American higher education it is beset by a horrible loss of faith and meaning that makes it an easy prey for what my friend Rod Dreher would called soft totalitarian forces, and worse, in Lewis’ book, demonic possession of a technocracy, but the two (totalitarianism and the demonic) seem to be related.
So with support from the Open Discourse Coalition I’ve developed a journalism course, already mentioned, a Great Books seminar, a course called “America at 250: Story and Documents,” and a course I’ll be co-teaching a course with the alumnus who heads ODC, Charles Mitchell, the former head of the Commonwealth Foundation of Pennsylvania, entitled “Conservatism and Its Discontents: The Many Faces of the American Right.” As an example of the liberal-arts content for that one, we’ll be teaching units on America’s Founding Fathers, Abraham Lincoln and Harry Jaffa, Freedom Conservatism and National Conservativism, the Reagan Coalition, Southern Conservatism and Paleo-conservatism, Green Conservatism vs. Transhumanism, etc. ODC also has helped support my Bible as Literature course by providing field-trip funds to visit the Museum of the Bible in DC. Faculty have been hostile to my offering the Bible as Literature class. As funds have gotten tighter at our university, the help from the alumni at the ODC becomes more attractive, another potential plus for potentially expanding its influence on campus.
At any rate, this is a mini-flotilla of courses designed to offer some revivified liberal arts on the margins. In the journalism course I do my best to weave in rhetoric and grammar in the broad sense of the classical liberal arts, including issues of poetics and narratology or storytelling in its best forms. In the Great Books Seminar, we discuss virtue, beauty, and truth, to the initial surprise of Bucknell students used to dealing primarily with race and sex in their humanities courses, and those topics only through activist slogans unfortunately, as is the case with much of American higher education.
In this flotailla of pirate-ship courses, I make use of an healthy elastic aspect of the Bucknell curriculum, that instructors can offer individual or group independent studies or regular courses for full or partial credit, sometimes under a cross-departmental designation, the instructor has additional leeway often in such course offerings. So with ODC’s support I’ve been able to develop some courses where students can take them for credit or for a non-credit certificate. In some cases ODC also offers students a small honorarium for taking a course, although that cannot be mixed with taking the course for university credit. This hybridity has been a helpful necessity given the opposition of key faculty leaders both to ODC, the merry band of dissenting faculty to which I belong, myself unworthily as an unimportant but often ostracized gadfly, and any curriculum that is not activist and advocacy filled from the racialist and pansexual standpoints that tend to dominate much American college curriculum today especially in the humanities. Such identitarianism runs counter, of course, to the Christian tradition underlying the liberal arts, which resists such ideological objectification of identity, and of self and others, as Elder Zosimas explained in The Brothers Karamazov when he spoke of how the relationality of different dimensions or worlds resists essentialism. That’s what the liberal arts with their Christian roots do, versus the ideologies of racialism and sexualism that often try to occupy curriculum today.
When a small group of us faculty at Bucknell proposed a first-year Great Books Residential College, we were literally stonewalled for several years, despite having good alumni support. Bucknell has a long-established first-year Social Justice Residential College, which the university supported even when it didn’t have enough enrollment. But just trying to find out how to apply to propose a new Great Books College has literally taken us years, without getting that information. And that situation continues.
We were told at an initial meeting about the Great Books College proposal that it was white supremacist. This humorously was by a Biology Professor with a leadership role at the time in Bucknell’s residential college system. Even when we pointed out that we planned to include books recognized as major works of literature from a variety of world cultures, we were dismissed in effect as neo-Nazis. But that same Professor who led the attack on our proposal subsequently established a study abroad program for Bucknell students to study wine and cheese in southern France. It is hard to get more colonialist and white supremacist than that :-). But such contradictions go unseen.
The Great Books Seminar I’ve started offering with support from ODC will hopefully form part of a Great Books certificate program in future. And there is always hope that perhaps that can be integrated fully into Bucknell’s curriculum directly in future. But the faculty themselves often seem as open to listening as the Soviet Politburo and probably share some common assumptions about the need to exterminate bourgeois notions of the liberal arts. Remember what the faculty did to the Chicago Principles on our campus, they prohibited even discussing them.
In my move toward teaching hopefully in future more Great Books seminar types of courses, for a certificate program, with support from ODC, and various kinds of credit options at the university, I have drawn on a definition of a Great Book as one that can be read over again and maybe multiple times for new meanings, that has general recognition across generations and cultures, and is important to be an informed person engaged in civilized discussions. They help provide a basis for civil discussion as noted at this conference. But in teaching Great Books, I also draw on my research into the history of the novel. In this I have found four elements related to the formative Christian culture of Late Antiquity in which the novel emerged in what today we’d call Greek Byzantine culture and beyond. Those four elements I argue are, one, overlay landscape, that is a spiritual landscape overlaying an actual representation of a physical geography. Two, a cosmic symbolism of marriage. Three, a relational sense of identity involving God as well as a community of others. And, four, otherworldly virtues, namely virtues that are not just legalistic but indicate a higher reality.
That gets me to a conclusion from my own Orthodox Christian tradition. In Orthodoxy, which was entwined with so-called Byzantine civilization, natural law was, as Tristram Engelhardt described it, the spark of God’s love in each human heart, rather than a more legalistic matrix., a more mystical view This gets back to my own sense of the liberal arts as relating logos as reason with logos as harmony and logos as story. Such understanding, from a Christian standpoint, will be important to any renewal of the liberal arts in American higher education I believe. That is also why much of my service work in recent years has been channeled into being an Orthodox clergyman and chaplain and also helping to found a small mission parish near campus, which just opened a new temple. We’ve had a small but for us large stream of young men converting recently. I think that in future, pirate efforts I support will need to be tied more closely in various ways to traditional Christianity, to avoid having the liberal arts, even in a renewal effort, be commandeered by the careerist and revolutionary interests of para-technocrats and para-communists who colonize the American higher-education landscape.
Now I’m finally at the end and offering a bit of hope from another source than alumni and beleaguered faculty. Last week, despite some university resistance, students met to sponsor a vigil against violence and in memory of Charlie Kirk. Just this past Tuesday, 35 highly energized students gathered to form a campus Turning Point chapter on our campus. They all individually expressed a high desire to engage in civil discourse as central to their liberal arts education, more than just political advocacy. Maybe there is hope after all. Thank you!